Selecting and applying a finish which is appropriate for the material used and the product design.

Resources → Subject Notes → Design and Technology → Lesson Plan

Cambridge A‑Level Design & Technology (9705) – Selecting and Applying an Appropriate Finish

1. Learning Objective

Students will be able to select and apply a finish that is appropriate for the material and product design, considering functional, aesthetic, economic, health‑&‑safety and sustainability factors.

2. Syllabus Alignment – Assessment Objectives

Assessment Objective (AO) What is assessed in this unit Exam weighting (approx.)
AO1 – Knowledge and understanding Properties of materials, processing stages, types of finishes, advantages/limitations, health & safety, environmental impact. ≈ 30 %
AO2 – Application of knowledge Choosing a finish for a given material and brief; carrying out surface preparation, finish application and curing. ≈ 30 %
AO3 – Analysis and evaluation Justifying finish selection using a weighted decision matrix; evaluating the finished product against the specification and sustainability criteria. ≈ 20 %
AO4 – Communication Presenting finish choices with sketches, tables, annotated diagrams and electronic symbols; recording process steps and quality‑control results. ≈ 20 %

3. How This Topic Fits Within the Full Design & Technology Programme

Design Process Stage Key Activities Link to Finishing (AO2/AO3)
1. Identify the problem Define brief, functional requirements, constraints. Finish requirements (corrosion, wear, appearance, ergonomics) are identified here.
2. Research Investigate materials, existing finishes, market trends, health & safety legislation. Provides data for the decision‑matrix and sustainability analysis.
3. Develop design specifications List performance, aesthetic, cost, environmental and safety criteria. Finish‑related criteria (colour, gloss, durability, VOC limits) are recorded.
4. Concept generation Sketches, CAD models, material‑finish combinations. AO4 – communicate options with annotated visuals and electronic symbols.
5. Detailed design Final drawings, bill of materials (BOM), process plan. Specify surface preparation, finish type, application method, safety precautions.
6. Manufacture & assemble Forming, machining, joining, heat‑treatment. Each preceding stage influences the surface condition for finishing.
7. Finishing (this unit) Surface preparation → finish application → curing → inspection → documentation. Core of AO1‑AO4 for this unit.
8. Test & evaluate Functional testing, aesthetic appraisal, cost review, sustainability audit. AO3 – evaluate whether the chosen finish meets the specification and environmental targets.
9. Review & improve Identify improvements for future iterations. Feedback may lead to alternative finishes or process changes.

4. Mapping to All Syllabus Topics (AS 1‑12 & A‑Level 13‑18)

Finishing is not an isolated activity; it touches every major syllabus topic. The table below shows the explicit connections.

Syllabus Topic Relevance to Finish Selection & Application
1 – Design process Finish decisions are made during specification, concept generation and detailed design.
2 – Design principles & good‑design criteria Functionality, aesthetics, ergonomics, sustainability and economy directly influence finish choice.
3 – Communication Use of drawings, surface‑finish symbols, colour keys and electronic symbols to convey finish information.
4 – Society & sustainable design Consider life‑cycle impact, VOC emissions, recyclability and ethical sourcing of finish chemicals.
5 – Health & safety Risk assessments for solvents, powders, blasting media, curing ovens and personal protective equipment (PPE).
6 – Aesthetics & ergonomics Colour, texture, gloss, slip‑resistance and tactile feel are controlled by the finish.
7 – Materials & components Compatibility of finishes with metals, polymers, ceramics and composites.
8 – Stages in processing Finishing is the final stage but is dependent on earlier forming, machining, joining and heat‑treatment.
9 – Energy & control Power requirements for spray guns, ovens, curing lamps; process‑control sensors and PLC logic.
10 – Technology Emerging finishes (e.g., PVD, nanocoatings) and digital tools (simulation of colour, virtual inspection).
11 – Industrial & commercial practice Batch size, lead time, cost estimation, quality‑management standards (ISO 9001).
12 – Quantity production Scalability of finishing processes – line‑side spray vs. batch powder coating.
13 – Quality systems Inspection methods, acceptance criteria, traceability of finish records.
14 – Emerging technologies Laser surface texturing, 3‑D printed functional finishes, bio‑based coatings.
15 – Digital technology Use of CAD/CAM for surface‑finish simulation, data‑logging of process parameters.
16 – Sustainable manufacturing Life‑cycle analysis of coating systems, waste‑minimisation, closed‑loop powder recovery.
17 – Health & safety in the workplace Specific regulations (COSHH, REACH) for chemicals used in finishing.
18 – Economic considerations Cost‑benefit analysis of high‑performance vs. low‑cost finishes.

5. Key Concepts Box (Six Core Concepts of the Syllabus)

Design & making in society – finishes affect product lifespan and environmental footprint.
Industrial practices – standardised coating lines, quality‑control protocols.
Design communication – surface‑finish symbols, colour keys, electronic control schematics.
Creative thinking – combining finishes (e.g., anodised + powder‑coated) for novel effects.
Sustainable design – low‑VOC, water‑based, recyclable coatings.
Emerging technologies – PVD, CVD, nanocomposite paints, UV‑LED curing.

6. Design Principles & Good‑Design Criteria (AO1)

  • Functionality – corrosion protection, wear resistance, friction, conductivity.
  • Aesthetics – colour, texture, gloss, transparency, brand identity.
  • Ergonomics – tactile feel, slip resistance, heat dissipation.
  • Sustainability – embodied energy, VOC emissions, recyclability, end‑of‑life options.
  • Economy – material cost, process cost, lead time, batch size.
  • Health & Safety – exposure to solvents, dust, high temperatures; PPE and ventilation requirements.

7. Communication Conventions (AO4)

  • Isometric and orthographic views to show overall shape.
  • Sectional views to illustrate surface‑preparation depth.
  • Surface‑finish symbols (e.g., Ra = 1.6 µm) according to BS 308.
  • Colour keys and texture swatches on exploded‑view diagrams.
  • Process flow‑charts using standard symbols (see electronic symbols list below).
  • Inspection records – tables for thickness, adhesion, corrosion‑test results.

8. Electronic Symbols Relevant to Finishing (p. 34 of the syllabus)

Symbol Name / Function
⏚ Power supply / mains connection (used for ovens, curing lamps).
⏚‑‑ Switch (manual start/stop of spray gun or conveyor).
⏚ → ⧖ Motor driving a conveyor or rotating part.
⧖ ⟶ ⧖ Sensor (e.g., temperature probe in a curing oven).
⧖ ⟶ ⏚ Actuator (e.g., solenoid valve controlling powder‑spray flow).
⚡ ⟶ ⧖ PLC or controller output to a process device.

9. Stages in Materials Processing – Emphasis on Finishing

  1. Raw‑material selection – Choose metal, polymer, ceramic or composite based on required properties.
  2. Forming / shaping – Casting, forging, extrusion, injection moulding, sheet‑metal forming – aim for near‑net shape to minimise later finishing.
  3. Machining / removal – Turning, milling, drilling, grinding, EDM – achieve dimensional accuracy and a baseline surface texture.
  4. Joining – Welding, brazing, adhesive bonding, mechanical fastening – ensure the joint area is compatible with the intended finish.
  5. Heat treatment – Annealing, quenching, tempering, ageing – may alter surface hardness and affect coating adhesion.
  6. Surface preparation – Cleaning, degreasing, abrasive blasting, polishing – creates a surface profile that promotes adhesion and removes contaminants.
  7. Finishing (core topic) – Application of protective or decorative layers (paint, powder coating, plating, anodising, etc.).

10. Selecting an Appropriate Finish – Decision‑Making Framework (AO2)

Use the checklist below to filter options before populating a weighted decision matrix.

  • Material compatibility – Does the finish adhere to the substrate? (e.g., anodising only for aluminium.)
  • Environmental exposure – Moisture, chemicals, UV, temperature cycles.
  • Mechanical demands – Wear, abrasion, impact, friction.
  • Design requirements – Colour, texture, gloss, transparency, branding.
  • Manufacturing constraints – Process temperature, equipment availability, batch size, lead time.
  • Cost & sustainability – Unit cost, energy consumption, waste, recyclability, VOC limits.
  • Health & safety – Hazardous chemicals, dust, noise, required PPE.

11. Common Finishes – Advantages, Limitations & Typical Applications

Finish Typical Materials Key Advantages Limitations Typical Applications
Paint (solvent‑based) Steel, aluminium, wood, polymers Wide colour range; easy to apply; low equipment cost. Requires thorough surface prep; can chip; VOC emissions. Consumer goods, furniture, automotive body panels.
Paint (water‑based) Steel, aluminium, wood, polymers Low VOC; good for indoor use; good colour retention. Longer drying time; may need higher film thickness for durability. Appliances, toys, indoor furniture.
Powder coating Steel, aluminium, zinc‑die‑cast alloys Durable, uniform thickness, environmentally friendly (no solvents). Requires curing oven (150‑200 °C); limited colour gradients. Outdoor equipment, appliances, architectural hardware.
Electroplating (chrome, nickel, zinc) Conductive metals – steel, brass, copper High wear & corrosion resistance; decorative shine. Complex setup; hazardous chemicals; thickness control critical. Tooling, automotive trim, bathroom fittings.
Anodising Aluminium alloys Hard porous oxide layer; can be dyed; excellent corrosion resistance. Only aluminium; colour limited to anodic dyes. Aerospace components, consumer‑electronics housings.
Varnish / lacquer Wood, polymers Enhances natural grain; provides moisture barrier. Susceptible to UV yellowing; may require re‑coating. Furniture, musical instruments, decorative panels.
Thermal spray (ceramic, metal) Metals, ceramics Very high wear resistance; can repair worn surfaces. Expensive equipment; relatively rough surface finish. Aerospace turbine blades, oil‑field components.
PVD (Physical Vapour Deposition) Metals, ceramics, polymers (with suitable priming) Ultra‑thin, hard, decorative coatings; low waste. High capital cost; line‑of‑sight process. Watch cases, medical instruments, high‑end consumer electronics.

12. Applying a Finish – Step‑by‑Step Process (AO2)

  1. Surface preparation
    • Degreasing with alkaline cleaner (e.g., 5 % NaOH solution).
    • Abrasive blasting to achieve Rₐ = 1.0–2.5 µm for optimal paint adhesion.
    • Final wipe‑down with lint‑free cloth and isopropyl alcohol.
    • Health & safety: wear respirator, goggles and disposable coveralls; ensure adequate ventilation.
  2. Application method
    • Spray – pressure 1.5–3 bar; nozzle distance 200 mm; overlap 50 %.
    • Dip – immersion time 30–60 s depending on viscosity.
    • Brush – for small repair areas; use low‑shear brushes.
    • Electro‑deposition – current density 0.5–2 A dm⁻²; bath temperature 20–30 °C.
    • UV‑cure – 365 nm LED, 200 mJ cm⁻², 5 s exposure.
  3. Curing / drying
    • Powder coating – convection oven, 150–200 °C for 10–15 min.
    • Solvent‑based paint – ambient air drying 24 h; optional bake at 80 °C for 30 min.
    • Anodising – sealing in hot water (90 °C) for 30 min.
    • UV‑cured systems – immediate polymerisation; no thermal cure required.
  4. Inspection & quality control
    • Visual check for runs, orange‑peel, pin‑holing.
    • Thickness measurement:
      • Magnetic gauge for ferrous substrates (target 30–80 µm for powder).
      • Ultrasonic gauge for non‑ferrous (target 20–60 µm).
    • Adhesion test – cross‑cut (ISO 2409) or pull‑off (ASTM D4541); acceptable > 1.5 MPa for most paints.
    • Corrosion test – salt‑spray (ASTM B117) for 48 h; no rusting indicates adequate protection.
    • Documentation – record batch number, operator, temperature, humidity, inspection results.

13. Decision‑Making Matrix – Example (AO3)

Rate each finish against the criteria identified in the checklist. Multiply the rating (1–5) by the weight (1–5) and sum to obtain a weighted score.

Criterion Weight (1‑5) Powder Coating Anodising Chrome Plating
Corrosion resistance 5 4 × 5 = 20 5 × 5 = 25 3 × 5 = 15
Wear resistance 4 3 × 4 = 12 5 × 4 = 20 5 × 4 = 20
Cost 3 4 × 3 = 12 2 × 3 = 6 2 × 3 = 6
Design flexibility (colour/texture) 4 5 × 4 = 20 2 × 4 = 8 3 × 4 = 12
Environmental impact 2 5 × 2 = 10 5 × 2 = 10 1 × 2 = 2
Total Score 74 69 55

In this example, powder coating obtains the highest weighted score, supporting its selection for a medium‑size outdoor aluminium‑alloy component.

14. Example Application – Finishing a Portable Power‑Tool Housing

  1. Brief: Durable, non‑slip grip, matte black appearance, resistance to oil and occasional drops.
  2. Material: Injection‑moulded ABS polymer.
  3. Finish options considered:
    • (a) Solvent‑based matte paint.
    • (b) Powder coating (requires metal insert – incompatible).
    • (c) UV‑cured clear coat over pre‑coloured ABS.
  4. Decision matrix (weights: durability 5, aesthetics 4, cost 3, process complexity 2):
    • Paint – 4 × 5 + 5 × 4 + 5 × 3 + 5 × 2 = 68
    • Powder – 2 × 5 + 3 × 4 + 2 × 3 + 1 × 2 = 31 (rejected – material incompatibility)
    • UV‑coat – 5 × 5 + 5 × 4 + 4 × 3 + 4 × 2 = 79
  5. Chosen finish: UV‑cured clear coat over pre‑coloured ABS – meets durability, aesthetics and cost targets while avoiding VOCs.
  6. Process summary:
    • Clean moulded part with isopropyl alcohol.
    • Apply pre‑coloured ABS pigment during injection moulding (in‑mould colour).
    • Apply UV‑cure clear coat (365 nm, 200 mJ cm⁻², 5 s).
    • Inspect gloss (target Rₐ ≈ 0.2 µm) and adhesion (cross‑cut ≥ 4B).

15. How This Unit Meets the Assessment Objectives

  • AO1 – Knowledge and understanding: Definitions of finishes, material compatibility tables, health‑&‑safety regulations, sustainability impacts.
  • AO2 – Application of knowledge: Checklist, decision‑making matrix, step‑by‑step application procedure, real‑world example (power‑tool housing).
  • AO3 – Analysis and evaluation: Weighted matrix calculation, post‑finish inspection data, cost‑benefit discussion, life‑cycle considerations.
  • AO4 – Communication: Use of surface‑finish symbols, colour keys, process flow‑charts with electronic symbols, tabulated results and annotated diagrams.

16. Summary of Key Points for Revision

  • Identify all functional, aesthetic, economic, health‑&‑safety and sustainability criteria before selecting a finish.
  • Use the decision‑making checklist and weighted matrix to justify the choice (AO3).
  • Follow a systematic surface‑preparation → application → curing → inspection routine (AO2).
  • Communicate finish information with correct symbols, colour keys and inspection records (AO4).
  • Always link the finish back to the six core concepts of the syllabus and the broader design‑process stages.

Create an account or Login to take a Quiz

33 views
0 improvement suggestions

Log in to suggest improvements to this note.