show a qualitative understanding of frictional forces and viscous/drag forces including air resistance (no treatment of the coefficients of friction and viscosity is required, and a simple model of drag force increasing as speed increases is sufficie

Momentum, Newton’s Laws and Resistive Forces (Cambridge International AS & A Level Physics – Syllabus 3.1 & 3.2)

Learning Objectives

  • Define linear momentum as a vector and write its fundamental relation.
  • State Newton’s three laws in their full form (including the momentum form of the 2nd law).
  • State the principle of conservation of momentum and apply it to elastic and inelastic collisions (one‑ and two‑dimensional).
  • Describe qualitatively how resistive forces (static/kinetic friction, viscous drag and air‑resistance) affect the motion and momentum of a body.
  • Explain terminal velocity and the exponential approach to it in the linear‑drag regime.
  • Plan a simple experiment to determine a drag constant.
  • Recognise links between resistive forces, work and energy.

1. Linear Momentum – definition and vector nature

Linear momentum of a particle of mass m moving with velocity v is

\[

\mathbf{p}=m\mathbf{v}

\]

  • m is a scalar, v is a vector; therefore p points in the same direction as the velocity.
  • Momentum measures the “quantity of motion”.

2. Newton’s Laws – full statements (including variable‑mass systems)

  1. First law (inertia): A body remains at rest or moves with constant velocity unless acted on by a net external force.
  2. Second law (momentum form): The net external force equals the rate of change of momentum,

    \[

    \mathbf{F}_{\text{net}}=\frac{d\mathbf{p}}{dt}.

    \]

    For constant mass this reduces to \(\mathbf{F}=m\mathbf{a}\).

    The same form also applies to variable‑mass systems (e.g. rockets) because the change of mass is automatically included in \(\mathbf{p}=m\mathbf{v}\).

  3. Third law: For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction.

3. Momentum Conservation (AO2)

  • If the resultant external force on a closed system is zero, the total momentum of the system is constant:

    \[

    \sum\mathbf{p}{\text{initial}}=\sum\mathbf{p}{\text{final}}.

    \]

  • Elastic collisions: both momentum and kinetic energy are conserved.
  • Inelastic collisions: momentum is conserved but kinetic energy is not. In a perfectly inelastic collision the bodies stick together after impact.

Worked example – perfectly inelastic collision (AO2)

Two carts on a frictionless track:

  • Cart A: mass \(m{A}=2.0\;\text{kg}\), velocity \(v{A}=3.0\;\text{m s}^{-1}\) to the right.
  • Cart B: mass \(m{B}=1.0\;\text{kg}\), velocity \(v{B}=0\) (at rest).

After they stick together, the common velocity \(v\) is found from momentum conservation:

\[

(m{A}+m{B})\,v = m{A}v{A}+m{B}v{B}

\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;

v = \frac{2.0\times3.0}{2.0+1.0}=2.0\;\text{m s}^{-1}\;\text{(to the right)}.

\]

The kinetic energy before collision is \( \tfrac12 m{A}v{A}^{2}=9\;\text{J}\); after collision it is \(\tfrac12 (m{A}+m{B})v^{2}=6\;\text{J}\). The loss of 3 J appears as internal energy (deformation, heat, sound).

4. Resistive Forces – overview

Resistive forces always act opposite to the instantaneous velocity of the body, thereby reducing its momentum.

4.1 Friction between solid surfaces

  • Static friction – prevents motion up to a maximum value; it automatically adjusts to match the applied force. No motion ⇒ no speed dependence.
  • Kinetic (sliding) friction – acts once motion has started; for a given pair of surfaces it is approximately constant:

    \[

    \mathbf{F}{\text{k}}=-F{k}\,\hat{\mathbf{v}},\qquad F_{k}\approx\text{constant}.

    \]

4.2 Viscous/drag forces in fluids

When an object moves through a liquid or a gas the fluid exerts a resistive force that depends on the speed.

  • Laminar (viscous) drag – low speeds

    \[

    \mathbf{F}{\text{drag}}=-k{1}v\,\hat{\mathbf{v}}\qquad (F\propto v)

    \]

    where \(k_{1}\) contains the fluid’s viscosity, the object’s characteristic size and shape.

  • Turbulent (inertial) drag – higher speeds

    \[

    \mathbf{F}{\text{drag}}=-k{2}v^{2}\,\hat{\mathbf{v}}\qquad (F\propto v^{2})

    \]

    where \(k{2}= \tfrac12 C{d}\rho A\) (drag coefficient \(C_{d}\), fluid density \(\rho\), cross‑sectional area \(A\)).

  • Transition speed \(v{c}\) – the speed at which the Reynolds number \(\displaystyle \text{Re}= \frac{\rho v L}{\mu}\) becomes of order \(10^{3}\). Below \(v{c}\) viscous drag dominates; above it turbulent drag dominates. (Optional but useful for AO2 reasoning.)

4.3 Air resistance – a piece‑wise model

For most A‑Level problems a simple two‑regime model suffices:

\[

\mathbf{F}_{\text{air}}=

\begin{cases}

-k{1}v\,\hat{\mathbf{v}}, & v{c}\ (\text{laminar})\\[4pt]

-k{2}v^{2}\,\hat{\mathbf{v}}, & v\ge v{c}\ (\text{turbulent})

\end{cases}

\]

5. Terminal Velocity – linking drag to momentum

When the downward weight of a falling body is exactly balanced by the upward drag, the net force is zero and the speed becomes constant – this is the terminal velocity \(v_{t}\).

  • Linear‑drag regime (\(F{\text{drag}}=k{1}v\)):

    \[

    mg = k{1}v{t}\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;v{t}= \frac{mg}{k{1}}.

    \]

  • Quadratic‑drag regime (\(F{\text{drag}}=k{2}v^{2}\)):

    \[

    mg = k{2}v{t}^{2}\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;v{t}= \sqrt{\frac{mg}{k{2}}}.

    \]

Exponential approach to terminal speed (linear drag)

Starting from rest, the equation of motion is

\[

m\frac{dv}{dt}=mg-k_{1}v.

\]

Solving gives

\[

v(t)=v_{t}\bigl(1-e^{-t/\tau}\bigr),\qquad

\tau=\frac{m}{k_{1}}.

\]

The speed rises exponentially and asymptotically approaches \(v_{t}\). This behaviour is a common AO2 expectation.

6. Practical Investigation – Determining a Drag Constant (AO3)

Suggested experiment (linear drag)

  1. Choose a small sphere of known mass \(m\) and diameter \(d\).
  2. Fill a tall transparent column with a viscous liquid (e.g. glycerol). Measure its density \(\rho\) and viscosity \(\mu\) (or look up the value).
  3. Release the sphere from rest at the top and use a stopwatch (or video analysis) to record the time \(t\) taken to travel a known distance \(s\) after the initial transient.
  4. Assuming the motion is in the linear‑drag regime, fit the data to

    \[

    s = v{t}\,t - \tau v{t}\bigl(1-e^{-t/\tau}\bigr)

    \]

    or, for the steady‑state region, simply use \(v\approx v{t}=mg/k{1}\) to obtain

    \[

    k{1}= \frac{mg}{v{t}}.

    \]

  5. Discuss sources of error (timing, buoyancy correction, temperature dependence of \(\mu\)) and suggest improvements.

7. How Resistive Forces Change Momentum

From Newton’s second law in momentum form:

\[

\frac{d\mathbf{p}}{dt}= \mathbf{F}{\text{net}} = -\mathbf{F}{\text{res}},

\]

where \(\mathbf{F}{\text{res}}\) is any of the forces listed above. Because \(\mathbf{F}{\text{res}}\) always points opposite to \(\mathbf{v}\), the magnitude of \(\mathbf{p}\) decreases. The rate of decrease is:

  • Fastest for a \(v^{2}\) drag (quadratic dependence).
  • Intermediate for linear (\(v\)) drag.
  • Constant for kinetic friction (independent of speed).

8. Comparison of Resistive Forces (Syllabus 3.1 & 3.2)

Force typeSpeed dependenceTypical exampleDirectionSyllabus outcome
Static frictionNone (zero speed)Block at rest on a rough tableOpposes impending motion3.1 – describe friction qualitatively
Kinetic friction≈ constant (independent of speed)Sliding crate on a floorOpposes direction of motion3.1 – describe friction qualitatively
Viscous (laminar) drag\(\propto v\)Sphere sinking slowly in oilOpposes velocity3.2 – explain effect of drag on motion
Inertial (turbulent) drag\(\propto v^{2}\)Car at highway speed, sky‑diverOpposes velocity3.2 – explain effect of drag on motion
Air resistance (piece‑wise model)Low \(v\): \(\propto v\); High \(v\): \(\propto v^{2}\)Anything moving through airOpposes velocity3.2 – describe terminal velocity

9. Example Scenarios (qualitative + short quantitative insight)

  • Block sliding on a rough floor – kinetic friction provides a constant deceleration \(a = -F{k}/m\). Speed falls linearly: \(v = v{0}-(F_{k}/m)t\).
  • Sphere falling through a viscous liquid (linear drag) – differential equation \(m\,dv/dt = mg - k{1}v\) gives the exponential solution shown in section 5. The speed approaches \(v{t}=mg/k{1}\) with time‑constant \(\tau=m/k{1}\).
  • Sky‑diver (quadratic drag) – initially \(v\) is small so linear drag is negligible; as \(v\) grows the quadratic term dominates until

    \[

    mg = k{2}v{t}^{2}\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;v{t}= \sqrt{\frac{mg}{k{2}}}\approx 55\;\text{m s}^{-1}

    \]

    (typical value). Acceleration decreases continuously and becomes zero at \(v_{t}\).

10. Connections to Work, Energy and Power

The work done by a resistive force over a displacement \(x\) is

\[

W{\text{res}} = \int \mathbf{F}{\text{res}}\cdot d\mathbf{x}.

\]

For kinetic friction \(W = -F_{k}x\) (linear loss).

For linear drag \(W = -k{1}\int v\,dx = -k{1}\int v^{2}\,dt\) (exponential loss).

For quadratic drag \(W = -k{2}\int v^{2}\,dx = -k{2}\int v^{3}\,dt\) (stronger loss at high speed).

These expressions link the momentum analysis to the energy‑conservation part of the syllabus (Section 4 “Work, energy and power”).

11. Summary (key take‑aways)

  • Momentum \(\mathbf{p}=m\mathbf{v}\) is a vector; Newton’s 2nd law in momentum form is \(\mathbf{F}=d\mathbf{p}/dt\) and applies to variable‑mass systems.
  • Conservation of momentum is a powerful tool for analysing collisions (elastic and inelastic).
  • Resistive forces always oppose motion and reduce momentum:

    • Kinetic friction ≈ constant.
    • Viscous (laminar) drag ∝ \(v\).
    • Turbulent drag ∝ \(v^{2}\).

  • Air resistance can be modelled with a simple piece‑wise function; the same ideas give terminal‑velocity expressions for both drag regimes.
  • In the linear‑drag regime the speed approaches terminal velocity exponentially: \(v(t)=v_{t}(1-e^{-t/\tau})\).
  • Practical experiments (e.g. dropping a sphere through a viscous fluid) allow determination of the drag constants \(k{1}\) or \(k{2}\).
  • Work done by resistive forces appears as a loss of kinetic energy, linking the momentum discussion to the energy‑conservation part of the syllabus.

Suggested diagrams (to be added by the teacher)

  • Block on a surface with an arrow showing kinetic friction opposite to motion.
  • Sphere moving through a fluid with arrows indicating the linear‑drag and quadratic‑drag regimes.
  • Velocity‑time graph for a falling body showing exponential rise to terminal speed (linear drag) and a smoother approach for quadratic drag.