Drawing and interpretation of average total cost (ATC) diagrams to illustrate economies and diseconomies of scale

Published by Patrick Mutisya · 14 days ago

Microeconomic Decision‑Makers – Firms

Learning Objective

Students will be able to draw and interpret an Average Total Cost (ATC) diagram to illustrate the presence of economies of scale and diseconomies of scale.

Key Concepts

  • Average Total Cost (ATC)
  • Economies of Scale
  • Diseconomies of Scale
  • Minimum Efficient Scale (MES)
  • Relationship between ATC, Marginal Cost (MC) and Total Cost (TC)

Definition of Average Total Cost

The average total cost is the total cost per unit of output:

\$ATC = \frac{TC}{Q}\$

where TC is total cost and Q is the quantity of output produced.

Step‑by‑Step: Drawing an ATC Curve

  1. Label the vertical axis “Cost per unit (£)” and the horizontal axis “Quantity of output (Q)”.
  2. Plot a series of points using the formula \$ATC = \frac{FC}{Q} + A \cdot C\$, where \$FC\$ is fixed cost and \$A \cdot C\$ is average variable cost.
  3. Connect the points with a smooth, U‑shaped curve.
  4. Identify the lowest point on the curve – this is the Minimum Efficient Scale (MES).
  5. Draw a marginal cost (MC) curve that intersects the ATC curve at its minimum point.

Interpreting the ATC Curve

The shape of the ATC curve reflects how average costs change as a firm expands production:

  • Downward‑sloping segment (left of MES): The firm experiences economies of scale. Average costs fall because fixed costs are spread over more units and because of factors such as specialization, bulk purchasing, and better utilisation of plant and equipment.
  • Minimum point (MES): The firm is operating at the most cost‑efficient scale. Any movement away from this point raises average costs.
  • Upward‑sloping segment (right of MES): The firm encounters diseconomies of scale. Average costs rise due to factors such as managerial inefficiency, coordination problems, and over‑use of equipment.

Suggested diagram: ATC curve showing a downward‑sloping portion (economies of scale), a minimum point (MES), and an upward‑sloping portion (diseconomies of scale) with the MC curve intersecting ATC at its minimum.

Comparison of Economies and Diseconomies of Scale

AspectEconomies of ScaleDiseconomies of Scale
Effect on ATCATC falls as output risesATC rises as output rises
Typical CausesTechnical (specialisation, larger plant), Purchasing (bulk discounts), Managerial (better planning), Financial (lower interest rates)Managerial (bureaucracy), Communication (delays), Over‑crowding of equipment, Labour morale issues
Location on ATC diagramLeft side of the minimum pointRight side of the minimum point
Strategic implicationEncourages expansion until MES is reachedSignals a need to limit further expansion or to reorganise production

Link to Other Economic Concepts

Understanding ATC is essential for analysing:

  • Profit maximisation – where marginal revenue (MR) equals marginal cost (MC) and the firm’s position relative to ATC determines profit or loss.
  • Market structures – firms in perfect competition, monopolistic competition, oligopoly and monopoly each face different cost‑curve implications.
  • Long‑run equilibrium – in the long run, firms tend to operate at the minimum of the ATC curve in competitive markets.