Drawing and interpretation of diagrams illustrating national minimum wages

Published by Patrick Mutisya · 14 days ago

IGCSE Economics 0455 – Workers: National Minimum Wages

Microeconomic Decision‑Makers: Workers

Learning Objective

Students will be able to draw and interpret a labour‑market diagram that illustrates the effect of a national minimum wage.

Key Concepts

  • Labour supply and demand curves
  • Equilibrium wage (\$We\$) and quantity of labour (\$Le\$)
  • National minimum wage (\$W_{min}\$)
  • Surplus of labour (unemployment) and surplus of wages (excess earnings for workers employed at \$W_{min}\$)
  • Potential efficiency losses (dead‑weight loss)

Step‑by‑Step Guide to Drawing the Diagram

  1. Draw a standard Cartesian plane. Label the vertical axis Wage (W) and the horizontal axis Quantity of Labour (L).
  2. Sketch an upward‑sloping labour‑supply curve (S) and a downward‑sloping labour‑demand curve (D).
  3. Mark the intersection of S and D as the equilibrium point E. Label the equilibrium wage \$We\$ and equilibrium quantity \$Le\$.
  4. Draw a horizontal line above \$We\$ to represent the national minimum wage \$W{min}\$. Extend this line across the diagram.
  5. From the \$W{min}\$ line, draw a vertical line down to the demand curve. The intersection gives the quantity of labour actually employed (\$L{min}\$).
  6. From the \$W{min}\$ line, draw a vertical line down to the supply curve. The intersection gives the quantity of labour that workers are willing to work at \$W{min}\$ (\$L_{s}\$).
  7. Shade the area between \$L{min}\$ and \$L{s}\$ on the horizontal axis – this represents the surplus of labour (unemployment).
  8. Shade the triangular area between the demand curve, the supply curve, and the \$W_{min}\$ line – this is the dead‑weight loss (efficiency loss).

Suggested diagram: Labour market with a national minimum wage set above equilibrium, showing surplus of labour (unemployment) and dead‑weight loss.

Interpretation of the Diagram

When \$W{min} > We\$:

  • The quantity of labour demanded falls from \$Le\$ to \$L{min}\$ because firms hire fewer workers at the higher wage.
  • The quantity of labour supplied rises from \$Le\$ to \$L{s}\$ as more workers are willing to work at the higher wage.
  • The difference \$L{s} - L{min}\$ is the surplus of labour, i.e., unemployment caused by the policy.
  • Workers who retain their jobs earn a higher wage, increasing their consumer surplus.
  • The dead‑weight loss represents the net loss in total surplus (both consumer and producer surplus) due to the market distortion.

Summary Table

AspectBefore Minimum WageAfter Minimum Wage (\$W{min} > We\$)
Equilibrium Wage\$W_e\$\$W_{min}\$ (higher)
Quantity of Labour Employed\$L_e\$\$L_{min}\$ (lower)
Quantity of Labour Supplied\$L_e\$\$L_{s}\$ (higher)
Unemployment (Surplus of Labour)None (market‑clearing)\$L{s} - L{min}\$ (positive)
Total Surplus (Consumer + Producer)Maximum (no distortion)Reduced by dead‑weight loss

Exam‑Style Questions

  1. Draw and label a labour‑market diagram showing the effect of a national minimum wage set above the equilibrium wage. Identify and shade the unemployment surplus and dead‑weight loss.
  2. Explain, using the diagram, why a minimum wage can lead to both higher earnings for some workers and higher unemployment for others.
  3. Discuss two arguments for and two arguments against the introduction of a national minimum wage in a developing country.

Key Points to Remember

  • The labour market behaves like any other market: price = wage, quantity = number of workers.
  • A binding minimum wage (set above equilibrium) creates a price floor.
  • Unemployment is measured as the horizontal distance between the labour‑supply and labour‑demand curves at \$W_{min}\$.
  • Policy effectiveness depends on the size of the surplus and the elasticity of supply and demand.