Describe the advantages and disadvantages of each method in terms of renewability, availability, reliability, scale and environmental impact

1 Motion, Forces & Energy

1.1 Speed, velocity and acceleration

  • Speed – scalar, \(v = \dfrac{s}{t}\) (m s⁻¹).
  • Velocity – vector, magnitude = speed, direction given by the line of motion.
  • Acceleration – change of velocity per unit time, \(a = \dfrac{\Delta v}{\Delta t}\) (m s⁻²).

Typical exam question: a car increases its speed from 10 m s⁻¹ to 30 m s⁻¹ in 5 s – calculate its acceleration.

1.2 Distance‑time and velocity‑time graphs

  • Gradient of a distance‑time graph = speed.
  • Gradient of a velocity‑time graph = acceleration.
  • Area under a velocity‑time graph = displacement.

Students should be able to sketch, interpret and calculate values from the three basic graph types.

1.3 Forces and motion

  • Resultant (net) force, \(\sum\mathbf{F}=m\mathbf{a}\) (Newton’s 2nd law).
  • Weight \(W=mg\) (downward), normal reaction, tension, friction (static & kinetic).
  • Moments: \(\tau = Fr\) – clockwise vs anti‑clockwise.

Practical: using a spring balance and a friction‑less air track to verify \(F=ma\).

1.4 Momentum and impulse

  • Momentum \(p = mv\).
  • Impulse \(J = F\Delta t = \Delta p\).
  • Conservation of momentum in collisions (elastic & inelastic).

1.5 Work, energy, power

  • Work \(W = F s \cos\theta\) (J). Positive when force has a component in the direction of motion.
  • Kinetic energy \(Ek = \frac12 mv^2\). Gravitational potential energy \(Ep = mgh\).
  • Conservation of energy – total energy before = total energy after (neglecting losses).
  • Power \(P = \dfrac{W}{t} = Fv = \dfrac{E}{t}\) (W).

1.6 Energy resources (1.7 in the syllabus)

1.6.1 Energy‑flow (Sankey) diagram

The diagram below shows the typical pathway from a primary energy source to the useful end‑use. It is the visual representation the syllabus expects students to be able to describe.

Primary source

Conversion

(e.g. turbine)

Electricity

End‑use

Fuel / Heat

Electrical power

Lighting, heating, transport …

1.6.2 Link to other syllabus sections

  • Section 2.3 (Heat transfer) – conversion of thermal energy from combustion.
  • Section 4.2 (Electrical energy and power) – generation of electricity in turbines and generators.
  • Section 4.5 (Power in electrical circuits) – distribution and use of generated electricity.
  • Section 5.2 (Nuclear physics) – fission process that powers nuclear reactors.

1.6.3 Efficiency – qualitative overview

Efficiency = (useful energy output ÷ total energy input) × 100 %.

  • Thermal plants (coal, oil, natural gas) – limited by the Carnot cycle; typical efficiencies: coal ≈ 30–35 %, oil ≈ 35–40 %, modern combined‑cycle gas ≈ 45–60 %.
  • Nuclear power – thermal efficiency ≈ 33 % but fuel energy density is ≈ 10⁸ times higher than coal.
  • Renewables – expressed as capacity factor (average output ÷ rated output):

    • Solar PV ≈ 15–20 %.
    • Wind ≈ 30–40 %.
    • Large‑scale hydro ≈ 50–90 % (steady flow).

  • Biomass – direct combustion ≈ 20 %; modern gasification up to ≈ 35 %.

1.6.4 Quantitative comparison of energy densities (per unit mass)

Energy sourceTypical energy densityTypical efficiency (thermal or capacity factor)
Coal≈ 24 MJ kg⁻¹30–35 %
Crude oil (gasoline)≈ 42 MJ kg⁻¹35–40 %
Natural gas (methane)≈ 55 MJ kg⁻¹45–60 % (combined‑cycle)
Uranium‑235 (fission)≈ 8 × 10⁷ MJ kg⁻¹≈ 33 % (thermal)
Solar PV (silicon)≈ 0.15 MJ kg⁻¹ (panel) → 15–20 % conversion15–20 %
Wind (average)≈ 0.5 MJ m⁻³ (air kinetic energy)30–40 % (capacity factor)
Hydro (large dam)Variable – depends on head and flow50–90 %
Geothermal (dry steam)≈ 0.1 MJ kg⁻¹ of water steam≈ 10–20 % (overall plant)

1.6.5 Energy sources – advantages, disadvantages & safety

Coal (solid fossil fuel)

FactorAssessment
RenewabilityNon‑renewable – formation takes millions of years.
AvailabilityLarge global reserves; uneven geographic distribution.
ReliabilityHigh – can be stock‑piled and used on demand.
ScaleVery large – single plants can generate several gigawatts.
Environmental impactHigh CO₂, SO₂, NOₓ, particulate emissions; ash disposal; acid‑rain contribution.
Safety considerationsDust explosions in handling; miners at risk of pneumoconiosis (black‑lung).
Advantages

  • Established infrastructure; low fuel cost.
  • Stable, controllable output.
  • High energy density per unit volume.

Disadvantages

  • Major source of greenhouse‑gas emissions.
  • Air‑quality and health impacts.
  • Finite resource.

Oil (liquid fossil fuel)

FactorAssessment
RenewabilityNon‑renewable.
AvailabilityLarge reserves but geopolitically concentrated.
ReliabilityHigh – can be stored in tanks and transported worldwide.
ScaleLarge – powers transport, industry and a substantial share of electricity generation.
Environmental impactCO₂ emissions, oil spills, SOₓ, NOₓ, particulates.
Safety considerationsSpill risk (marine & land), fire hazard, occupational exposure.
Advantages

  • Very high energy density (≈ 42 MJ kg⁻¹).
  • Versatile – fuels transport, heating, industry.
  • Extensive distribution network.

Disadvantages

  • Contributes to climate change.
  • Spill‑related habitat damage.
  • Finite supply.

Natural gas (primarily methane)

FactorAssessment
RenewabilityNon‑renewable.
AvailabilityAbundant in many regions; transported via pipelines or LNG ships.
ReliabilityHigh – can be stored as compressed gas or liquefied.
ScaleLarge – major contributor to national grids.
Environmental impactLower CO₂ per MJ than coal, but methane leakage (potent GHG) can offset benefits.
Safety considerationsFlammable; explosion risk if leaks occur; requires strict pipeline monitoring.
Advantages

  • Cleaner combustion (less SO₂, NOₓ, particulates).
  • High efficiency in combined‑cycle plants (45–60 %).
  • Quick start‑up and shut‑down.

Disadvantages

  • Methane leakage contributes strongly to global warming.
  • Still a finite fossil resource.
  • Infrastructure cost for pipelines or LNG terminals.

Nuclear power (fission)

FactorAssessment
RenewabilityNon‑renewable (uranium finite) but fuel use is extremely low per unit energy.
AvailabilityUranium resources are globally distributed; breeder reactors could extend supply.
ReliabilityVery high – provides baseload power 24 h day⁻¹.
ScaleLarge – a single reactor can exceed 1 GW electrical output.
Environmental impactLow CO₂ during operation; issues include radioactive waste, mining impact and rare accidents.
Safety considerationsRadiation protection, robust containment, emergency shutdown (SCRAM), waste management.
Advantages

  • Very low greenhouse‑gas emissions.
  • High power density – small land footprint.
  • Continuous, controllable output.

Disadvantages

  • Radioactive waste requires long‑term management.
  • High capital cost and long construction periods.
  • Public concern over safety and proliferation.

Solar photovoltaic (PV)

FactorAssessment
RenewabilityRenewable – sunlight is virtually inexhaustible on human timescales.
AvailabilityWidely available; intensity varies with latitude, season and weather.
ReliabilityIntermittent – generation only when the sun shines; storage or backup needed.
ScaleModular – from small rooftop systems (~1 kW) to utility‑scale farms (> 500 MW).
Environmental impactLow operational emissions; manufacturing uses hazardous chemicals and electricity (often from the grid).
Safety considerationsElectrical‑shock risk during installation; fire hazard if panels are damaged.
Advantages

  • No fuel cost; electricity is free after installation.
  • Scalable and can be sited close to demand.
  • Quiet, low‑maintenance, long lifespan (~25 years).

Disadvantages

  • Low capacity factor (≈ 15–20 %).
  • Large land area needed for utility farms.
  • Performance falls with high temperature.

Wind power

FactorAssessment
RenewabilityRenewable – wind is continuously replenished by solar heating of the atmosphere.
AvailabilityBest in coastal, offshore and high‑latitude sites; varies with time.
ReliabilityIntermittent – output depends on wind speed; need grid integration or storage.
ScaleModular – from small 100 W turbines for homes to 3–5 MW offshore units.
Environmental impactLow emissions; visual impact, noise and possible bird/bat collisions.
Safety considerationsBlade‑failure risk; safe siting away from populated areas.
Advantages

  • No fuel cost; low operating cost.
  • High capacity factor in windy regions (30–40 %).
  • Scalable and can be added incrementally.

Disadvantages

  • Intermittent; requires backup or storage.
  • Site‑specific – not suitable everywhere.
  • Infrastructure (roads, transmission) can be expensive.

Hydroelectric power (large dam)

FactorAssessment
RenewabilityRenewable – water cycle is driven by solar energy.
AvailabilityDepends on geography (river flow, head). Good in mountainous regions.
ReliabilityHighly reliable; can provide baseload and rapid load‑following.
ScaleVery large – megawatt to gigawatt plants.
Environmental impactLow emissions; but reservoir flooding can affect ecosystems and displace communities.
Safety considerationsDam failure risk; requires rigorous monitoring.
Advantages

  • High efficiency (50–90 %).
  • Long‑life, low operating cost.
  • Can store water for peak‑load generation.

Disadvantages

  • Geographically limited.
  • High initial capital and environmental/social impacts.
  • Susceptible to droughts.

Geothermal (dry‑steam & binary)

FactorAssessment
RenewabilityRenewable on human timescales where heat flow is sustained.
AvailabilityLimited to tectonically active regions (e.g., Iceland, New Zealand, parts of USA).
ReliabilityHigh – provides baseload power, not weather dependent.
ScaleTypically 10–100 MW per field; can be expanded.
Environmental impactLow emissions; possible release of trace gases, land subsidence.
Safety considerationsHigh temperature fluids; need corrosion‑resistant materials.
Advantages

  • Stable, continuous output.
  • Small land footprint.
  • Low operating cost after development.

Disadvantages

  • Geographically restricted.
  • High upfront drilling costs.
  • Potential for induced seismicity.

Biomass (solid, liquid or gas)

FactorAssessment
RenewabilityRenewable if biomass is replanted or waste is used.
AvailabilityAbundant in agricultural regions; depends on land use.
ReliabilityCan be stored and dispatched like fossil fuels.
ScaleFrom small domestic stoves to 100 MW power stations.
Environmental impactCO₂ released, but considered part of short‑term carbon cycle; air‑quality concerns if combustion is incomplete.
Safety considerationsDust explosion risk; handling of bio‑fuels.
Advantages

  • Utilises waste materials.
  • Can provide baseload power.
  • Reduces dependence on imported fossil fuels.

Disadvantages

  • Lower energy density than fossil fuels.
  • Land competition with food production.
  • Potential deforestation if not managed sustainably.


2 Thermal Physics

2.1 Particle model & states of matter

  • Solids – particles vibrate about fixed positions; high density.
  • Liquids – particles close together but can move past each other; definite volume, no fixed shape.
  • Gases – particles far apart; fill container, pressure arises from collisions.

2.2 Temperature, heat and specific heat capacity

  • Temperature scales: Celsius (°C), Kelvin (K) – \(T(K)=t(°C)+273\).
  • Heat energy: \(Q = mc\Delta T\) (J), where \(c\) is specific heat capacity.
  • Latent heat: \(Q = mL\) for phase change (fusion, vaporisation).

Practical: heating equal masses of aluminium and copper and measuring temperature rise to determine \(c\).

2.3 Heat transfer

  • Conduction – transfer through solids; rate \( \dot Q = \dfrac{kA\Delta T}{d}\).
  • Convection – transfer by fluid motion; natural vs forced.
  • Radiation – electromagnetic waves; Stefan‑Boltzmann law \(P = \varepsilon\sigma A T^{4}\).

Experiment ideas: metal‑rod conduction test, heated water convection cell, infrared camera to view radiative heat loss.


3 Waves

3.1 Wave properties

  • Wave speed: \(v = f\lambda\) (m s⁻¹).
  • Frequency \(f\) (Hz) – number of cycles per second.
  • Wavelength \(\lambda\) – distance between successive crests.
  • Amplitude – maximum displacement from equilibrium.

3.2 Reflection, refraction & diffraction

  • Law of reflection: angle of incidence = angle of reflection.
  • Refraction: \( \dfrac{\sin i}{\sin r} = \dfrac{v1}{v2}\) (Snell’s law).
  • Diffraction – bending around obstacles; more pronounced when obstacle size ≈ wavelength.

Practical: ripple tank to observe all three phenomena with a point source and a slit.

3.3 Sound

  • Longitudinal wave; speed in air ≈ 340 m s⁻¹ (temperature dependent).
  • Pitch ∝ frequency; loudness ∝ amplitude.
  • Resonance – standing waves in tubes (open‑closed, open‑open).

3.4 Light

  • Electromagnetic wave; visible spectrum 400–700 nm.
  • Behaviour similar to water waves: reflection, refraction, total internal reflection, diffraction.
  • Lens formula: \(\dfrac{1}{f} = \dfrac{1}{do} + \dfrac{1}{di}\).


4 Electricity & Magnetism

4.1 Charge, electric field & potential difference

  • Charge \(q\) measured in coulombs (C); like charges repel, opposite attract.
  • Electric field \(E = \dfrac{F}{q}\) (N C⁻¹); direction of force on a positive test charge.
  • Potential difference \(V = \dfrac{W}{q}\) (V); work done moving charge between two points.

4.2 Current, resistance & Ohm’s law

  • Current \(I = \dfrac{q}{t}\) (A).
  • Resistance \(R = \dfrac{V}{I}\) (Ω); depends on material, length, cross‑section, temperature.
  • Power \(P = VI = I^{2}R = \dfrac{V^{2}}{R}\) (W).

Experiment: constructing series and parallel circuits with a bulb, ammeter and voltmeter to verify Ohm’s law.

4.3 Series and parallel circuits

  • Series – same current, voltages add; total resistance \(R{T}=R{1}+R_{2}+…\).
  • Parallel – same voltage, currents add; \(\dfrac{1}{R{T}} = \dfrac{1}{R{1}}+\dfrac{1}{R_{2}}+…\).

4.4 Domestic wiring & safety

  • Standard UK supply: 230 V AC, 50 Hz.
  • Protective devices: fuses, circuit breakers, RCDs.
  • Colour coding of conductors (brown live, blue neutral, green/yellow earth).

4.5 Magnetic fields

  • Field lines emerge from north pole, enter south pole.
  • Force on a moving charge: \(\mathbf{F}=q\mathbf{v}\times\mathbf{B}\).
  • Force on a current‑carrying conductor: \(F = BIL\sin\theta\).

4.6 Electromagnetic induction

  • Faraday’s law: induced emf \(\mathcal{E}= -\dfrac{d\Phi}{dt}\).
  • Lenz’s law – direction of induced current opposes change in flux.
  • Applications: AC generators, transformers, induction cookers.

Practical: moving a magnet through a coil and measuring the induced voltage with a galvanometer.


5 Radioactivity & Nuclear Physics

5.1 Types of radiation

  • Alpha (\(\alpha\)) – helium nucleus, +2 e, low penetration, stopped by paper.
  • Beta (\(\beta\)) – high‑speed electron (or positron), moderate penetration, stopped by aluminium foil.
  • Gamma (\(\gamma\)) – high‑energy photons, high penetration, requires lead or concrete shielding.

5.2 Radioactive decay & half‑life

  • Decay law: \(N = N_{0}e^{-\lambda t}\) where \(\lambda\) is decay constant.
  • Half‑life \(t_{1/2} = \dfrac{\ln2}{\lambda}\).
  • Applications: carbon dating, medical imaging (PET, gamma cameras), sterilisation.

5.3 Nuclear reactions

  • Fission – heavy nucleus splits, releasing neutrons, large energy release (≈ 200 MeV per fission).
  • Fusion – light nuclei combine (e.g., D + T → He + n), releases even more energy; requires extremely high temperature/pressure.

5.4 Safety & applications

  • Shielding, distance, time principle for protection.
  • Uses: electricity generation, cancer treatment (radiotherapy), food irradiation.
  • Issues: radioactive waste, proliferation, accidental release.