relationship between the balance of payments and inflation

Links Between Macro‑Economic Problems – Balance of Payments & Inflation

Learning Objectives

• Explain how the balance of payments (BoP) and inflation interact.
• Analyse the two‑way causal links and the policy implications.
• Place this relationship within the wider set of macro‑economic objectives and inter‑relationships required by Cambridge IGCSE/A‑Level Economics (Syllabus 9708, Section 10).

---

1. Basic Economic Ideas & Resource Allocation (AS‑Level 1.1‑1.6)

1.1 Economic Methodology

• Positive statement: “Unemployment fell by 2 % in the last quarter.” (testable, descriptive)
• Normative statement: “The government should increase the minimum wage to reduce poverty.” (value‑judgement, prescriptive)
• Economists use ceteris paribus – “all other things being equal” – to isolate cause‑and‑effect relationships.

1.2 Specialisation & Comparative Advantage

Countries specialise in producing goods for which they have a lower opportunity cost. Example: Brazil has a comparative advantage in coffee because its climate and labour skills make coffee production relatively cheap compared with, say, electronics. By trading, both Brazil and a country that specialises in electronics can enjoy more coffee and more phones than if they tried to produce both goods domestically.

1.3 Division of Labour & Gains from Trade

• Division of labour → higher productivity (Adam Smith’s pin factory).
• Increased output → lower unit costs → lower prices for consumers.

---

2. The Price System & Microeconomics (AS‑Level 2.1‑2.5)

2.1 Demand and Supply

Use a standard market‑equilibrium diagram. Diagram tip: Sketch a demand curve (downward sloping) and a supply curve (upward sloping). Mark the equilibrium price (P*) and quantity (Q*). Show a shift (e.g., a rise in consumer income) that creates a surplus or shortage.

2.2 Elasticities

• Price elasticity of demand (PED): |%ΔQd / %ΔP|. Elastic (>1) when consumers can easily substitute; inelastic (<1) for necessities.
• Price elasticity of supply (PES): |%ΔQs / %ΔP|.
  Short‑run: Firms cannot change plant size → supply relatively inelastic.
  Long‑run: Firms can adjust capacity → supply becomes more elastic.
• Income elasticity, cross‑price elasticity – useful for analysing demand for imports/exports.

2.3 Consumer & Producer Surplus

On the demand‑supply diagram, the area above price and below demand = consumer surplus; the area below price and above supply = producer surplus. These illustrate the welfare gain from market exchange.

---

3. Government Micro‑Intervention (AS‑Level 3.1‑3.3)

3.1 Reasons for Intervention

• Market failure (externalities, public goods, information asymmetry).
• Equity – redistributing income or wealth.
• Macro‑economic stability (controlling inflation, unemployment).

3.2 Main Tools

Tool	How it Works	Typical Advantage	Typical Disadvantage
Taxes (excise, specific, ad‑valorem)	Raise price of targeted good	Can correct negative externalities	May create dead‑weight loss; incidence depends on elasticity
Subsidies	Lower price for producers or consumers	Encourages production of merit goods	Fiscal cost; risk of over‑production
Price controls (ceilings, floors)	Set legal maximum/minimum price	Protect consumers (ceilings) or producers (floors)	Can cause shortages (ceilings) or surpluses (floors)
Regulation (licensing, standards)	Set legal requirements for entry or production	Improves safety, quality	Administrative costs; may limit competition

3.3 Evaluation Box (example for a specific tax)

• Advantage: Reduces consumption of cigarettes, lowering health‑related external costs.
• Disadvantage: If demand is inelastic, the tax raises revenue but does little to cut smoking; also creates a regressive burden on low‑income smokers.

3.4 Government Failure

Occurs when intervention does not achieve the intended outcome or causes larger net costs.

• Information problems: Policymakers lack accurate data (e.g., hidden unemployment).
• Political constraints: Short‑term electoral cycles favour stimulus that creates long‑run imbalances.
• Administrative inefficiency: Bureaucratic delays, corruption, misallocation.
• Unintended side‑effects: Price caps → shortages; subsidies → dead‑weight loss.
• Regulatory capture: Industries influence regulators to design rules that favour incumbents.

---

4. Government Macro‑Economic Objectives (Syllabus 10.1)

Objective	Definition	Typical Trade‑offs
Economic Growth	Increase in real GDP over time.	May raise inflation or widen the BoP deficit if growth is export‑driven.
Full Employment	Low, stable unemployment (often measured by the natural rate).	Expansionary policies that reduce unemployment can increase inflation (Phillips‑curve trade‑off).
Price Stability (Low Inflation)	Keeping the general price level stable, usually < 2 % CPI.	Tight monetary policy can curb inflation but may depress growth and raise unemployment.
External Stability (Balance of Payments)	Avoid persistent current‑account deficits or surpluses; maintain a sustainable exchange rate.	Policies that improve the BoP (e.g., a weaker currency) can raise import prices and inflation.
Equitable Distribution of Income	Reduce income inequality through taxation, welfare, etc.	Redistributive policies can affect incentives, potentially slowing growth.
Economic Development	Long‑run improvement in living standards, health, education, infrastructure.	Large public investment may increase debt and pressure the BoP.

---

5. Links Between Macro‑Economic Problems (Syllabus 10.2)

Cambridge requires discussion of five two‑way relationships. The table summarises each link, the main mechanisms, and the typical direction of causality.

Link	Key Mechanism(s)	Effect of an Increase in the First Variable	Effect on the Second Variable
Money‑value ↔ External‑value	Real exchange rate, price level, nominal exchange rate.	Higher domestic price level (inflation) → real appreciation.	Exports become less competitive; current‑account deficit widens.
Balance of Payments ↔ Inflation	Exchange‑rate movements, import‑price pass‑through, monetary financing.	Current‑account deficit → currency depreciation.	Higher import prices → upward pressure on CPI.
Growth ↔ Inflation	Demand‑pull pressures, cost‑push effects, Phillips curve.	Rapid output growth → higher aggregate demand.	Upward pressure on prices (inflation).
Growth ↔ Balance of Payments	Import demand, export‑capacity, terms of trade.	Higher GDP → larger import bill.	Current‑account deficit may widen unless export growth matches.
Inflation ↔ Unemployment	Phillips curve (short‑run), expectations‑augmented curve (long‑run).	Lower unemployment → higher wage pressure.	Higher wages → higher unit costs → inflation.

---

6. Detailed Relationship: Balance of Payments ↔ Inflation

6.1 How Inflation Affects the Balance of Payments

1. Real Exchange‑Rate Appreciation

   When domestic prices rise faster than foreign prices, the real exchange rate (RER) increases, making domestic goods relatively expensive.

   $$\varepsilon = \frac{E\,P^{*}}{P}$$ where $\varepsilon$ = real exchange rate, $E$ = nominal exchange rate (home currency per unit of foreign currency), $P^{*}$ = foreign price level, $P$ = domestic price level.

   • Higher $\varepsilon$ → export volumes fall, import volumes rise → current‑account deficit widens.
2. Substitution Towards Cheaper Imports

   Higher domestic prices make imported goods relatively cheaper, increasing import demand and the import bill.

3. Terms‑of‑Trade Deterioration

   If export prices are relatively rigid while import prices rise, the terms of trade (export price index ÷ import price index) fall, reducing export earnings.

4. Capital‑Account Outflows

   Expectations of future inflation erode real returns on domestic assets, prompting investors to move funds abroad (portfolio outflows), worsening the financial account.

6.2 How a BoP Deficit Can Generate Inflation

1. Exchange‑Rate Depreciation

   A persistent current‑account deficit puts downward pressure on the domestic currency. Depreciation raises the local‑currency price of imports, feeding directly into the CPI.

2. Import‑Price Inflation

   In economies that rely heavily on imported intermediate goods (oil, food, machinery), higher import prices translate quickly into higher production costs and consumer prices.

3. Monetary Financing of the Deficit

   If the central bank purchases foreign currency to keep the exchange rate from falling, the domestic money supply expands. The resulting demand‑pull pressure raises the overall price level.

4. Expectations & Wage‑Price Spirals

   Continued deficits may undermine confidence in the currency, leading workers to demand higher wages to preserve real earnings. Higher wages increase unit costs, prompting firms to raise prices—a self‑reinforcing inflationary loop.

6.3 Suggested Diagram (Flow‑Chart)

Draw two linked arrows:

• Domestic Inflation → Real Exchange‑Rate Appreciation → Export Competitiveness ↓ → Current‑Account Deficit ↑
• Current‑Account Deficit → Currency Depreciation → Import‑Price Rise → CPI ↑ → Inflation ↑

Label each arrow with the underlying mechanism (price‑level change, exchange‑rate movement, import‑price pass‑through).

---

7. Policy Options & Their Effectiveness (Syllabus 10.3)

Policy Tool	Primary Target(s)	Impact on Inflation	Impact on BoP	Typical Effectiveness / Limitations
Expansionary Monetary Policy (lower rates, QE)	Growth, Employment	↑ Inflation (demand‑pull)	May worsen BoP if lower rates cause currency appreciation; can improve BoP if they lead to depreciation via capital outflows.	Quick to implement; limited when interest rates are already low (liquidity trap).
Contractionary Monetary Policy (higher rates, OMO sales)	Price Stability	↓ Inflation	Currency tends to appreciate → export competitiveness falls → BoP may deteriorate.	Effective for curbing inflation; can raise unemployment.
Expansionary Fiscal Policy (higher G, tax cuts)	Growth, Employment	↑ Inflation (if near full capacity)	Higher import demand → current‑account deficit widens.	Political lag; raises public debt.
Contractionary Fiscal Policy (higher taxes, spending cuts)	Price Stability, Debt Reduction	↓ Inflation	Reduced import demand → BoP improves.	Can depress growth and raise unemployment.
Supply‑Side Measures (education, infrastructure, deregulation)	Long‑run Growth, Inflation (cost‑push)	↓ Inflation (greater productive capacity)	Improved competitiveness → export growth → BoP improves.	Long implementation lag; needs political consensus.
Exchange‑Rate Intervention (buy/sell reserves)	External Stability	Indirect – a stronger currency can lower import‑price inflation.	Direct – can correct a temporary BoP imbalance.	Limited by reserve levels; may provoke “currency wars”.
Trade Policy (tariffs, quotas, export subsidies)	BoP, Domestic Industries	Can be inflationary if tariffs raise import prices.	Tariffs improve current‑account balance but risk retaliation.	Often conflicts with WTO rules; reduces consumer welfare.

---

8. Government Failure (Re‑visited)

Definition: Situations where government intervention does not achieve the intended objective, or where the costs of intervention exceed the benefits.

• Information problems – lack of reliable data (e.g., hidden unemployment, informal sector).
• Political constraints – short‑term electoral incentives favour stimulus that creates long‑run imbalances.
• Administrative inefficiency – bureaucratic delays, corruption, misallocation.
• Unintended side‑effects – price controls → shortages; subsidies → dead‑weight loss.
• Regulatory capture – industries influence regulators to design rules that favour incumbents.

In the BoP‑inflation context, a common failure is financing a persistent current‑account deficit by printing money, which fuels high inflation without solving the external imbalance.

---

9. A‑Level Extensions (Syllabus 10.4‑10.5, 11.1‑11.6)

---

10. Summary Table of the BoP ↔ Inflation Channels

Direction	Channel	Effect on BoP	Effect on Inflation
Inflation → BoP	Real exchange‑rate appreciation	Exports ↓, imports ↑ → current‑account deficit widens	—
Inflation → BoP	Higher import demand (substitution effect)	Import bill ↑ → deficit widens	—
BoP Deficit → Inflation	Currency depreciation	—	Import‑price inflation raises CPI
BoP Deficit → Inflation	Monetary financing of the deficit	—	Money‑supply growth → demand‑pull inflation
BoP Deficit → Inflation	Expectations‑driven wage‑price spiral	—	Higher wage demands → cost‑push inflation

---

11. Key Take‑aways for Examination

• State the causal chain clearly:
  • Domestic inflation → real exchange‑rate appreciation → export competitiveness ↓ → current‑account deficit ↑.
  • Current‑account deficit → currency depreciation → import‑price rise → CPI ↑ → inflation.
• Use the real exchange‑rate formula to show how relative price changes affect competitiveness.
• Discuss at least two policy responses (e.g., monetary tightening vs. exchange‑rate intervention) and evaluate their likely effectiveness and side‑effects.
• Remember to mention possible government failure when evaluating policy options.
• Include a simple diagram or flow‑chart to illustrate the two‑way link.

---

12. Sample Examination Question

“Using appropriate diagrams and economic theory, evaluate how a rise in domestic inflation can affect a country’s balance of payments, and how a persistent current‑account deficit can, in turn, generate inflationary pressures. In your answer, discuss at least two policy options and assess their likely effectiveness.”