issues of comparison using monetary indicators

Resources → Subject Notes → Economics → Lesson Plan

Cambridge AS & A Level Economics – Economic Development: Monetary Indicators & Syllabus Overview

Learning Objectives (AO1‑AO3)

  • AO1 – Knowledge & Understanding: Explain why monetary indicators are used, describe how they are measured and identify the main strengths and limitations when comparing countries.
  • AO2 – Application: Use real‑world data to calculate real GDP, GDP‑per‑capita, PPP‑adjusted figures and illustrate how exchange‑rate movements or inflation affect comparisons.
  • AO3 – Analysis & Evaluation: Critically assess the reliability of monetary indicators, discuss the impact of non‑monetary factors (inequality, informal sector, structural differences) and suggest complementary measures.

1. Syllabus Mapping – AS (9708)

Syllabus Block (Code) Key Content Coverage in These Notes
1.1‑1.6 – Basic Economic Ideas & Resource Allocation Scarcity, opportunity cost, factors of production, economic systems, PPC, classification of goods. Expanded (Section 2) – includes PPC analysis, shape, shifts and full classification of goods.
2.1‑2.5 – Demand & Supply, Elasticity, Surplus Demand‑supply diagram, determinants, PED & PES, consumer/producer surplus. Expanded (Section 3) – adds price‑elasticity of supply, worked surplus example.
3.1‑3.3 – Government Micro‑intervention Reasons for intervention, taxes & subsidies, price controls, merit‑demerit goods, incidence. Expanded (Section 4) – includes graphical incidence analysis and link to elasticity.
4.1‑4.6 – Macro‑economics (NI, AD/AS, Growth, Unemployment, Inflation) GDP/GNI, circular flow, AD/AS model, types of unemployment, CPI & inflation measurement. Expanded (Section 5) – detailed circular‑flow with injections/leakages, all unemployment types, CPI basket & base‑year discussion.
5.1‑5.4 – Fiscal, Monetary & Supply‑side Policy Government spending & taxation, interest rates & money supply, AD/AS effects, crowding‑out, supply‑side measures. Expanded (Section 6) – AD/AS shift diagrams for each policy, explicit crowding‑out explanation.
6.1‑6.5 – International Trade & Finance Comparative advantage, terms of trade, balance of payments, exchange‑rate regimes, trade protection. Expanded (Section 7) – terms‑of‑trade index calculation, simple BOP diagram, exchange‑rate impact on monetary indicators.
7‑11 – A‑Level Extensions (optional) Utility, market failure, labour markets, multiplier, development indicators, globalisation. Fully covered (Section 8) – utility & indifference curves, externalities, public goods, labour‑demand, multiplier, HDI, Gini, gender index.

2. Core Economic Concepts (AS) – Quick Reference

  • Scarcity & Choice: Unlimited wants vs limited resources → need to allocate efficiently.
  • Opportunity Cost: The next best alternative foregone; illustrated on a Production Possibility Curve (PPC).
  • Production Possibility Curve (PPC):
    • Shows maximum output combinations of two goods.
    • Shape (concave) reflects increasing opportunity cost.
    • Shifts:
      • Outward – economic growth, technological progress, increase in factors.
      • Inward – war, natural disaster, loss of resources.
  • Factors of Production: Land, labour, capital, entrepreneurship.
  • Economic Systems: Market, command, mixed – degree of government intervention.
  • Classification of Goods:
    • Private vs public
    • Rival vs non‑rival
    • Merit & demerit goods
    • Club goods (non‑rival, excludable)
    • Common‑pool goods (rival, non‑excludable)

3. Demand, Supply & Elasticity

  • Demand‑Supply Diagram: Price (vertical), Quantity (horizontal); equilibrium where D = S.
  • Determinants of Demand: Income, tastes, price of related goods, expectations, number of buyers.
  • Determinants of Supply: Input prices, technology, expectations, number of sellers, taxes/subsidies.
  • Price Elasticity of Demand (PED): $$\text{PED}= \frac{\%\Delta Q_d}{\%\Delta P}$$
    • Elastic (|PED| > 1), Inelastic (|PED| < 1), Unit‑elastic (|PED| = 1).
  • Price Elasticity of Supply (PES): $$\text{PES}= \frac{\%\Delta Q_s}{\%\Delta P}$$
    • Determinants: time period, spare capacity, mobility of factors.
  • Consumer & Producer Surplus:
    • Consumer surplus = area above price & below demand curve.
    • Producer surplus = area below price & above supply curve.
    Worked Example (price = $10, demand intercept = $20, quantity = 100):
    Consumer surplus = ½ × (20‑10) × 100 = $500.
    Producer surplus = ½ × (10‑0) × 100 = $500.

4. Government Micro‑intervention

  • Reasons for Intervention: Market failure, equity, macro‑stability, political objectives.
  • Taxes:
    • Shift supply curve leftwards (tax on producers) or demand curve leftwards (tax on consumers).
    • Tax incidence depends on relative elasticities:
      • If demand is inelastic & supply elastic → producers bear most of the burden.
      • If supply is inelastic & demand elastic → consumers bear most of the burden.
  • Subsidies:
    • Shift supply rightwards (producer subsidy) or demand rightwards (consumer subsidy).
    • Incidence follows the same elasticity logic as taxes.
  • Price Controls:
    • Price ceiling (max price) → shortage if set below equilibrium.
    • Price floor (minimum price) → surplus if set above equilibrium.
  • Merit & Demerit Goods: Government subsidises merit goods (education, health) and taxes/demonetises demerit goods (tobacco, alcohol).

5. Macro‑economics Snapshot

  • National Income Accounting:
    • Nominal GDP = Σ (P × Q) at current prices.
    • Real GDP = Nominal GDP ÷ (1 + inflation rate). (or use price index: Real = Nominal ÷ (PPI/100)).
    • GDP per capita = Real GDP ÷ population.
    • GNI = GDP + net primary income from abroad.
  • Circular Flow (Open Economy):
    • Households ↔ Firms (goods & factor markets).
    • Government injects (G, transfers) and extracts (taxes).
    • Rest of World injects (exports, capital inflows) and extracts (imports, remittances).
    • Key terms: Leakages = savings, taxes, imports; Injections = investment, government spending, exports.
  • AD/AS Model:
    • AD = C + I + G + (NX).
    • Short‑run AS (SRAS) upward‑sloping; Long‑run AS (LRAS) vertical at potential output.
    • Policy impacts are shown as shifts of AD or AS (see Section 6).
  • Unemployment Types:
    • Frictional – short‑term job search.
    • Structural – mismatch of skills/locations.
    • Cyclical – due to insufficient aggregate demand.
    • Seasonal – predictable variations (agriculture, tourism).
    • Technological – caused by automation.
  • Inflation Measurement:
    • Consumer Price Index (CPI) = (Cost of basket in current year ÷ Cost of basket in base year) × 100.
    • Rate of inflation = (CPI_t – CPI_{t‑1}) ÷ CPI_{t‑1} × 100.
    • Limitations: substitution bias, exclusion of new goods, difficulty measuring informal consumption.

6. Fiscal, Monetary & Supply‑side Policy

  • Fiscal Policy:
    • Expansionary: ↑G or ↓T → AD shifts right.
    • Contractionary: ↓G or ↑T → AD shifts left.
    • Crowding‑out: Higher government borrowing can raise interest rates, reducing private investment and partially offsetting the AD boost.
  • Monetary Policy (Central bank tools):
    • Interest‑rate policy, open‑market operations, reserve requirements.
    • Expansionary: ↓interest rates → ↑I & C → AD rightward.
    • Contractionary: ↑interest rates → ↓I & C → AD leftward.
  • Supply‑side Measures:
    • Deregulation, tax cuts for firms, investment in R&D, training, infrastructure.
    • Shift LRAS right (higher potential output) and may also shift SRAS right in the medium term.
  • AD/AS Shift Summary (useful for AO3 evaluation):
    PolicyPrimary AD/AS ShiftShort‑run EffectLong‑run Effect
    Expansionary fiscalAD rightHigher output & price levelPossible crowding‑out → AD may fall back
    Contractionary fiscalAD leftLower output & price levelReduced crowding‑out → AD stabilises
    Expansionary monetaryAD rightHigher output & price levelRisk of inflation if not matched by supply
    Contractionary monetaryAD leftLower output & price levelMay improve price stability
    Supply‑side reformsLRAS right (and SRAS right)Higher potential output, lower price pressureSustained growth without inflation

7. International Trade & Finance (Key for Monetary Comparisons)

  • Comparative Advantage: Countries specialise where marginal opportunity cost is lower.
  • Terms of Trade (ToT) Index: $$\text{ToT}= \frac{\text{Export Price Index}}{\text{Import Price Index}}\times 100$$
    Improvement (>100) means export prices have risen relative to import prices.
  • Balance of Payments (BOP) Diagram:
    • Current account (trade balance, services, income, transfers).
    • Capital account (transfers of non‑produced assets).
    • Financial account (direct investment, portfolio investment, other investment).
    • Errors & omissions ensure the sum = 0.
  • Exchange‑rate Regimes:
    • Fixed (pegged), floating (market‑determined), managed float.
    • Exchange‑rate movements affect nominal GDP when expressed in a common currency and can distort comparisons if not adjusted.
  • Protectionism: Tariffs, quotas, import licences – can reduce export earnings and alter monetary indicators such as GDP.

8. A‑Level Extensions (Full Coverage)

8.1 Utility Theory & Indifference Curves

  • Utility: Satisfaction derived from consumption; total utility vs marginal utility.
  • Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility: MU falls as more of a good is consumed.
  • Indifference Curve (IC):
    • Shows combinations of two goods giving equal satisfaction.
    • Downward‑sloping, convex to the origin (reflects diminishing MRS).
    • Higher IC = higher utility.
  • Budget Constraint: $P_xX + P_yY = I$; slope = –$P_x/P_y$.
  • Consumer equilibrium where the highest attainable IC is tangent to the budget line (MRS = $P_x/P_y$).

8.2 Market Failure & Government Intervention

  • Externalities:
    • Positive (e.g., education) – government may subsidise.
    • Negative (e.g., pollution) – tax or regulation (Pigouvian tax).
  • Public Goods: Non‑rival & non‑excludable (national defence, street lighting); market under‑provides → government provision.
  • Information Asymmetry: Adverse selection & moral hazard; solutions include regulation, certification.
  • Government Failure: Policy lag, bureaucratic inefficiency, rent‑seeking.

8.3 Labour Market

  • Demand for Labour: Derived from marginal product of labour (MPL); downward‑sloping curve.
  • Supply of Labour: Influenced by population, participation rates, wages.
  • Wage Determination:
    • Competitive market → equilibrium wage.
    • Monopsony → wage below marginal revenue product.
  • Trade Unions & Minimum Wage: Can create a wage floor, potentially causing unemployment if set above equilibrium.
  • Labour‑market Policies: Training, active labour‑market programmes, unemployment benefits (impact on frictional & structural unemployment).

8.4 Multiplier & Crowding‑out

  • Fiscal Multiplier: $$k = \frac{1}{1 - MPC(1 - t) + MPI}$$ where MPC = marginal propensity to consume, t = tax rate, MPI = marginal propensity to import.
  • Crowding‑out revisited: Higher government borrowing raises interest rates, reducing private investment; net effect on AD depends on size of multiplier vs crowding‑out.

8.5 Advanced Development Indicators

  • Human Development Index (HDI): Composite of life expectancy, education (mean + expected years), GNI per capita (PPP).
  • Gini Coefficient: Measures income inequality (0 = perfect equality, 1 = perfect inequality).
  • Gender Inequality Index (GII): Captures gender gaps in reproductive health, empowerment, labour market participation.
  • These non‑monetary indicators complement GDP/GNI when evaluating development.

Economic Development – Issues of Comparison Using Monetary Indicators

8.1 Why Use Monetary Indicators?

  • Provide a quantifiable, internationally comparable measure of economic size and performance.
  • Data are regularly published by reputable sources (World Bank, IMF, UN) and allow time‑series analysis.
  • Form the basis for many policy decisions (aid allocation, investment decisions, trade negotiations).

8.2 Key Monetary Indicators

  • Nominal Gross Domestic Product (GDP) – market value of all final goods & services produced in a year, measured at current prices.
  • Real GDP – adjusts nominal GDP for inflation: $$\text{Real GDP}= \frac{\text{Nominal GDP}}{1+\pi}$$ where $\pi$ = inflation rate (decimal).
  • GDP per capita – Real GDP ÷ population; gives an average income per person.
  • Gross National Income (GNI) – GDP + net primary income from abroad.
  • Purchasing Power Parity (PPP)‑adjusted GDP – converts GDP into a common price level to reflect the amount of goods & services that can be bought with a unit of currency.
  • Human Development Index (HDI) – combines GNI per capita, education and health; often used alongside monetary measures.

8.3 Problems When Comparing Monetary Indicators

  1. Exchange‑rate fluctuations – Nominal GDP expressed in USD can be distorted by short‑term currency moves.
  2. Inflation differences – High inflation inflates nominal values; real GDP corrects this, but price indices may be unreliable in some economies.
  3. Population size – Larger populations naturally have higher total GDP; per‑capita figures are needed but can mask inequality.
  4. Informal & non‑market activities – Not captured in official statistics, leading to under‑estimation in many developing countries.
  5. Data quality & coverage – Some states have outdated or incomplete accounts, especially in conflict zones.
  6. Time lags – GDP data are released with a delay; comparisons may involve different reference periods.
  7. Distribution of income – Averages hide how income is shared; a high GDP per capita can coexist with high poverty.
  8. Structural differences – Service‑based economies vs agriculture‑based economies may have different productivity levels not reflected in monetary terms alone.

8.4 Illustrative Comparison Table

Country Nominal GDP (US$ bn) Real GDP per capita (US$) GDP (PPP) per capita (US$) GNI per capita (US$) HDI (0–1)
Country A 1,200 15,000 22,500 16,200 0.78
Country B 850 12,800 19,400 13,500 0.71
Country C 300 9,200 14,800 9,800 0.65

8.5 Example Calculations

8.5.1 Converting Nominal GDP to Real GDP

Country X reports a nominal GDP of $500 bn and an inflation rate of 6 %.

$$\text{Real GDP}= \frac{500}{1+0.06}= \frac{500}{1.06}\approx 471.7\text{ bn}$$

Using real GDP removes the effect of price‑level changes, allowing a fairer comparison over time or with other economies.

8.5.2 Adjusting for Purchasing Power Parity

PPP conversion factor (PPP / Market exchange rate) = 0.75 for Country Y.

$$\text{GDP (PPP)} = \text{Nominal GDP} \times \frac{1}{\text{PPP conversion factor}}$$

If nominal GDP = $400 bn:

$$\text{GDP (PPP)} = 400 \times \frac{1}{0.75}= 533.3\text{ bn}$$

The PPP‑adjusted figure shows that, in terms of domestic purchasing power, Country Y’s economy is larger than the nominal US‑dollar value suggests.

8.5.3 Calculating the Terms of Trade Index

Export Price Index = 115, Import Price Index = 95.

$$\text{ToT}= \frac{115}{95}\times100\approx 121$$

A ToT > 100 indicates that export prices have risen relative to import prices, improving the country’s trade position.

8.6 Critical Evaluation Checklist

  • Have you used real rather than nominal values?
  • Is a per‑capita measure appropriate for the comparison you are making?
  • Did you apply a PPP adjustment where price‑level differences are significant?
  • Are you aware of the size of the informal sector in each country?
  • Do you consider income distribution (e.g., Gini coefficient) alongside monetary averages?
  • Is the data source recent and reliable (World Bank, IMF, UN)?
  • Have you examined structural differences (resource base, sectoral composition) that may affect the interpretation of monetary figures?
  • Do you complement monetary indicators with non‑monetary measures such as HDI, Gini, or gender indices?

Create an account or Login to take a Quiz

43 views
0 improvement suggestions

Log in to suggest improvements to this note.