changes in the exchange rate under different exchange rate systems

Exchange Rates – A‑Level Economics (9708)

1. What is an exchange rate?

An exchange rate (E) is the price of one currency expressed in terms of another. It is normally quoted as the amount of domestic currency required to buy one unit of foreign currency (e.g. £/$, €/£).

1.1 Nominal vs real exchange rates

  • Nominal exchange rate (E): the market price of the foreign currency in domestic‑currency units.
  • Real exchange rate (R): the relative price of domestic goods to foreign goods, taking price levels into account.

    Formula (Cambridge syllabus 11.2.1):

    $$R = \frac{E \times P^{*}}{P}$$ where \(P^{*}\) = foreign price level, \(P\) = domestic price level.

1.2 Trade‑weighted (index) exchange rate

  • A trade‑weighted rate aggregates a country’s exchange rates against a basket of its major trading‑partner currencies, weighted by each partner’s share of total trade.
  • It is usually expressed as an index (base year = 100).

    Formula:

    $$E_{TW}= \sum_{i=1}^{n} w_i\,E_i$$ where \(w_i\) = proportion of trade with partner i, \(E_i\) = bilateral nominal exchange rate.
  • Example (UK): if 40 % of trade is with the Eurozone, 30 % with the US, 20 % with Japan and 10 % with the rest of the world, the UK trade‑weighted rate is a weighted average of £/€, £/$ and £/¥.

2. Exchange‑rate systems

Cambridge distinguishes between systems that are policy‑anchored (the authority sets the rate) and those that are market‑driven (the rate is primarily determined by supply and demand). The table below summarises the main regimes, how the rate is set, typical drivers of change, policy tools, and a brief pros‑cons list (AO3).

System How the rate is set / maintained Typical drivers of change Policy tools available Pros / Cons (summary)
Fixed (Pegged) Exchange Rate Central bank commits to buying/selling foreign currency at a predetermined parity \(E_{peg}\); the peg is defended with foreign‑exchange reserves. Changes in demand for foreign currency (capital outflows, import booms) force reserve transactions. Reserve sales/purchases, interest‑rate adjustments, capital controls, occasional revaluation/devaluation.
  • + Exchange‑rate stability → predictable trade and investment.
  • – Loss of monetary‑policy autonomy; large reserve requirements.
Floating (Flexible) Exchange Rate Rate is determined entirely by market forces – the intersection of foreign‑exchange supply and demand. Relative price changes, interest‑rate differentials, expectations about future rates (uncovered interest parity). Monetary policy (interest rates, open‑market operations), macro‑prudential measures.
  • + Full monetary‑policy independence.
  • – Potential for high volatility; can transmit external shocks.
Managed Float (Dirty Float) Central bank intervenes occasionally to keep the rate within a pre‑announced band (e.g. ±2 % of a central parity). Market forces drive the rate; intervention caps excessive moves. Foreign‑exchange swaps, direct buying/selling, sterilised or non‑sterilised interventions, band‑adjustment rules.
  • + Reduces excessive volatility while retaining some monetary flexibility.
  • – Requires credible commitment; interventions can be costly.
Crawling Peg Fixed parity that is adjusted regularly (daily, weekly or monthly) by a small, pre‑announced amount to reflect inflation differentials. Gradual depreciation/appreciation in line with the announced schedule. Scheduled revaluation/devaluation, reserve operations, limited discretion.
  • + Predictable adjustments; helps avoid sudden crises.
  • – Still limits monetary autonomy; credibility depends on reserve adequacy.
Currency Board Domestic currency is fully backed 1:1 (or at a fixed ratio) by foreign reserves; the monetary base expands or contracts only as reserves change. Any shock leads to an immediate, automatic adjustment of the monetary base; the exchange rate itself never moves. Only reserve accumulation or loss; no independent monetary policy.
  • + Maximum exchange‑rate credibility; eliminates devaluation risk.
  • – No monetary‑policy freedom; vulnerable to reserve outflows.
Dollarisation / Euroisation The country abandons its own currency and adopts a foreign currency for all transactions. Exchange‑rate risk disappears; domestic price changes affect competitiveness directly. Fiscal policy, structural reforms (monetary policy is set by the foreign‑currency authority).
  • + Immediate exchange‑rate stability; lower inflation risk.
  • – Complete loss of monetary sovereignty; reliance on external fiscal discipline.

3. Fixed‑rate mechanics – revaluation and devaluation

  • Revaluation: an official upward adjustment of the peg (domestic currency becomes stronger). Used to combat inflation or to reflect an improvement in the terms of trade.
  • Devaluation: an official downward adjustment of the peg (domestic currency becomes weaker). Used to restore competitiveness when a persistent trade deficit exists.
Diagram (suggested): Foreign‑exchange market under a fixed peg. The horizontal line at \(E_{peg}\) shows the central bank’s commitment; reserve sales (left shift of supply) or purchases (right shift) keep the market price at the peg.

4. Managed‑float – detailed mechanics (syllabus 11.2.2)

  • The central bank announces a central parity \(E_{0}\) and an allowable band, for example \(E_{0}\pm 2\%.\)
  • If the market rate \(E_{m}\) stays inside the band, the bank does not intervene.
  • If \(E_{m}\) breaches the band:
    • \(E_{m} > E_{0}+2\%\) (domestic currency depreciating too fast) → bank sells foreign reserves to buy domestic currency.
    • \(E_{m} < E_{0}-2\%\) (domestic currency appreciating too fast) → bank buys foreign reserves, injecting domestic currency.
  • Intervention can be:
    • Sterilised – offset by open‑market operations so that the domestic money supply is unchanged.
    • Non‑sterilised – allowing the money supply to expand or contract, reinforcing the exchange‑rate move.
Diagram (suggested): Managed‑float band. The central line is the announced parity \(E_{0}\); the shaded area shows the ±2 % band. Arrows illustrate central‑bank buying (when the rate falls below the lower limit) and selling (when it rises above the upper limit).

5. Floating (flexible) exchange rate – market determination (syllabus 11.2.3)

  • The exchange rate is the equilibrium where the supply of domestic currency (people wanting to sell it for foreign currency) equals the demand for domestic currency (people wanting to buy it).
  • Key determinants:
    • Relative price levels (inflation differentials) – affect export‑import competitiveness.
    • Interest‑rate differentials – capital flows respond to higher returns.
    • Expectations of future rates – captured by uncovered interest parity: $$i = i^{*} + \frac{E^{e}-E}{E}$$ where \(i\) and \(i^{*}\) are domestic and foreign interest rates, \(E^{e}\) is the expected future exchange rate.
  • Because the central bank does not set a target, policy influence is indirect (through interest rates, open‑market operations, or macro‑prudential measures).
Diagram (suggested): Supply‑and‑demand curves in the foreign‑exchange market. The equilibrium point determines the floating exchange rate.

6. Effects of exchange‑rate changes on the external economy (syllabus 11.2.4)

  • Marshall‑Lerner condition: a depreciation improves the trade balance if the sum of the absolute values of the export‑price elasticity (\(\varepsilon_X\)) and the import‑price elasticity (\(\varepsilon_M\)) exceeds 1: $$|\varepsilon_X| + |\varepsilon_M| > 1.$$ When this holds, the price effect (imports become more expensive, exports cheaper) outweighs the volume effect.
  • J‑curve effect: after an initial depreciation, the trade balance may **worsen** before it improves because contracts are sticky and import volumes adjust slowly. Over time, as quantities respond, the balance moves toward the Marshall‑Lerner outcome.
  • Link to the balance of payments (BoP):
    • Exchange‑rate movements affect the **current account** through the price‑effect (expenditure‑switching) and the quantity‑effect (expenditure‑reducing).
    • In a fixed regime, a loss of reserves can lead to a **balance‑of‑payments crisis**; in a floating regime, the exchange rate itself absorbs the external shock.
Sketch of the J‑curve: the vertical axis shows the current‑account balance, the horizontal axis time. After a depreciation the balance first falls (point A) then improves (point B) as elasticities kick in.

7. How exchange rates change under each system – “what‑if” table (inflation shock)

System Shock: ↑ domestic inflation Likely exchange‑rate movement Policy response
Fixed (Pegged) Higher domestic prices reduce export competitiveness → pressure on foreign reserves. Reserve outflow; if reserves become insufficient the peg may be abandoned → sudden depreciation. Raise interest rates, impose capital controls, or officially devalue the peg.
Floating Domestic goods become relatively expensive. Market‑driven depreciation (E rises). Monetary tightening (higher i) to support the currency; no direct control over E.
Managed Float Same as floating, but the central bank may intervene if the move breaches the band. Initial depreciation; if the band is breached the bank sells reserves (or sterilises). Band‑based intervention, possible sterilisation, temporary interest‑rate adjustment.
Crawling Peg Inflation differential is reflected in the scheduled adjustment. Gradual, pre‑announced depreciation in line with the crawl. Adjust the crawl rate; use reserves to maintain credibility.
Currency Board Inflation does not affect the exchange rate; it erodes the real value of reserves. No exchange‑rate change; possible loss of reserves if capital flight occurs. Only reserve‑building measures; monetary policy unavailable.
Dollarisation / Euroisation Domestic inflation directly reduces competitiveness. No exchange‑rate adjustment – the foreign currency is fixed. Fiscal consolidation and structural reforms to boost productivity.

8. Exam‑style checklist (AO1‑AO3)

  1. Identify the exchange‑rate regime being used (fixed, floating, managed float, crawling peg, currency board, dollarisation).
  2. Explain the mechanism that moves the exchange rate under that regime (e.g., reserve sales/purchases, market supply‑demand, band‑triggered intervention).
  3. Analyse the impact of a specific shock (interest‑rate change, inflation, terms‑of‑trade shift, capital‑flow reversal) on the exchange rate.
  4. Discuss the policy tools available to the government/central bank and evaluate their likely effectiveness (pros‑cons, short‑ vs long‑run).
  5. Weigh the advantages and disadvantages of the regime in terms of exchange‑rate stability, monetary‑policy independence, and external vulnerability.

9. Summary

Exchange‑rate regimes fall into two broad categories:

  • Policy‑anchored – fixed peg, crawling peg, currency board, dollarisation. The authority deliberately sets the rate and bears the burden of defending it.
  • Market‑driven – floating and managed float. The rate is primarily set by supply and demand, with the central bank intervening only to limit excessive volatility.

The choice of regime determines:

  • How quickly the exchange rate responds to shocks.
  • Which economic channels (interest rates, reserves, fiscal policy) are available to stabilise the economy.
  • The trade‑off between exchange‑rate stability and monetary‑policy independence.

Understanding these mechanisms is essential for analysing balance‑of‑payments problems, inflation transmission, and the scope of monetary policy at A‑Level.

Create an account or Login to take a Quiz

44 views
0 improvement suggestions

Log in to suggest improvements to this note.