the impact of Total Quality Management (TQM) on a business

9.2 Quality Management – Quality Control, Assurance & Total Quality Management

Learning Objective

Understand the impact of Total Quality Management (TQM) on a business and how it influences performance, competitiveness and stakeholder relationships.

Key Concepts

  • Quality Control (QC): Operational techniques used to detect and correct defects in products or services.
  • Quality Assurance (QA): Systematic processes that give confidence that quality requirements will be met consistently.
  • Total Quality Management (TQM): An organisation‑wide philosophy that seeks continuous improvement in all processes, involving every employee.

Quality Control (QC)

Definition & Purpose

QC aims to identify non‑conforming items and eliminate waste before they reach the customer. It is usually carried out at the point of production or during final inspection.

Common QC Methods – Purpose, Typical Use & Business Impact

Method Purpose Typical Use Impact on Business
Inspection Identify non‑conforming items End‑of‑line or spot checks Reduces warranty claims → lower external‑failure costs; improves customer satisfaction.
Statistical Process Control (SPC) Monitor process variation in real time Continuous monitoring of key dimensions or cycle times Detects trends early → less scrap & re‑work → lower internal‑failure costs and higher productivity.
Control Charts Visualise stability of a process Plotting defect rates, cycle times, etc. Helps maintain process capability → shorter lead‑times and reduced downtime.
Six‑Sigma DMAIC Define‑Measure‑Analyse‑Improve‑Control to reduce variation Complex, high‑volume processes where 3.4 defects per million opportunities is the target Significant cost savings (often 10‑30% of total production cost) and strong brand reputation.

Quality Costing – The Four Categories

Understanding where money is spent on quality helps managers decide where to invest in improvement.

Category Description Typical Examples How It Is Measured
Prevention Costs Costs incurred to avoid defects occurring Training, process design, quality‑planning, supplier qualification Budgeted expense vs. actual spend; ROI calculated from subsequent failure‑cost reductions.
Appraisal Costs Costs of evaluating products/services to ensure they meet standards Inspection, testing, SPC, calibration of equipment Number of inspections × cost per inspection; percentage of total production cost.
Internal‑Failure Costs Costs of defects found before delivery to the customer Scrap, re‑work, downtime, waste, reject handling Value of scrap + re‑work labour + lost production time.
External‑Failure Costs Costs of defects discovered after delivery Warranty claims, returns, recalls, loss of goodwill, legal expenses Warranty payments + cost of replacements + estimated loss of future sales.

Quality Assurance (QA)

Definition & Purpose

QA builds quality into processes rather than testing for it after the fact. It creates a systematic environment that gives confidence that specifications will be met consistently.

Key Standards

  • ISO 9001 – Quality Management Systems
  • ISO 14001 – Environmental Management (often integrated with quality)
  • ISO/TS 16949 – Automotive industry quality
  • ISO 13485 – Medical devices

Typical QA Activities

  • Documented procedures, work instructions and process maps
  • Internal audits and management reviews
  • Supplier quality assurance & certification programmes
  • Corrective and Preventive Action (CAPA) processes
  • Training and competence assessment

Impact of QA on Business

  • Reduced Failure Costs: By preventing defects, QA lowers both internal‑ and external‑failure costs.
  • Improved Reputation & Market Access: ISO certification is often a prerequisite for tendering, opening new markets and attracting quality‑sensitive customers.
  • Consistent Delivery: Standardised processes lead to predictable lead‑times, supporting better inventory management and customer service.
  • Enhanced Decision‑Making: Audits and KPI dashboards provide reliable data for strategic planning.

Benchmarking – Learning from the Best

Benchmarking compares a company’s processes and performance with those of leading organisations.

  • Types
    • Internal – comparing departments or plants within the same firm.
    • External – comparing with competitors or best‑in‑class firms.
  • Typical Metrics: defect rates, lead times, cost per unit, customer‑satisfaction scores.
  • Example: A car manufacturer reduced its defect rate from 4 % to 1 % after benchmarking its assembly line against a Japanese rival known for “just‑in‑time” quality.

Core Elements of TQM

Element Description Typical Tools
Customer Focus Understanding and meeting customer needs and expectations. Surveys, Voice of the Customer (VoC), Net Promoter Score (NPS)
Continuous Improvement (Kaizen) Ongoing effort to enhance products, services and processes. PDCA cycle, Six‑Sigma, Benchmarking
Employee Involvement All staff participate in quality activities and decision‑making. Quality circles, Training programmes, Suggestion schemes
Process‑Centred Approach Viewing work as interrelated processes rather than isolated tasks. Process mapping, Flowcharts, Value‑stream analysis
Integrated System Quality is embedded in the organisation’s strategy, culture and systems. ISO 9001, Balanced Scorecard, ERP quality modules

Impact of TQM on Business Performance

Link each impact to the four A‑Level business objectives (profitability, growth, market share, stakeholder satisfaction).

  1. Cost Reduction – Elimination of waste and defects lowers production costs.
    • Profitability: Higher margins.
  2. Improved Product Quality – Fewer returns, warranty claims and re‑work.
    • Stakeholder Satisfaction: Customers and shareholders gain confidence.
  3. Increased Customer Satisfaction & Loyalty – Consistently meeting expectations encourages repeat purchases and positive word‑of‑mouth.
    • Market Share: Retention and acquisition of new customers.
  4. Enhanced Competitive Advantage – Differentiation through reliability, speed and innovation.
    • Growth: Ability to enter new markets or launch premium products.
  5. Employee Motivation & Retention – Involvement in problem‑solving improves morale and reduces turnover.
    • Stakeholder Satisfaction: Better labour relations and lower recruitment costs.
  6. Better Decision‑Making – Data‑driven quality metrics give accurate information for strategic planning.
    • Profitability & Growth: Informed investment decisions.

Potential Challenges When Implementing TQM

  • Resistance to change, especially from middle management.
  • Initial investment in training, new equipment and software.
  • Difficulty in measuring intangible benefits such as morale or brand reputation.
  • Need for sustained leadership commitment and clear communication.

Case Study Outline – Applying TQM in a Manufacturing Firm

  1. Background of the firm and its quality issues.
  2. Steps taken to implement TQM (training, process mapping, quality circles, benchmarking).
  3. Quantitative outcomes (e.g., defect rate reduced from 5 % to 1 %).
  4. Qualitative outcomes (customer feedback, employee engagement scores).
  5. Lessons learned and recommendations for other businesses.

Connections to Other Operations Topics

  • Lean Production – waste reduction complements TQM’s continuous improvement.
  • Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) – integrates quality data across finance, production and sales.
  • Computer‑Aided Production (CAP) – real‑time monitoring supports SPC and control charts.
Suggested diagram: Flowchart of the PDCA (Plan‑Do‑Check‑Act) cycle illustrating continuous improvement in TQM.

Summary Checklist – Evaluating TQM Impact

  • Has the defect rate decreased? (Provide % change)
  • Are production costs lower? (Show cost comparison)
  • Is customer satisfaction improving? (Reference survey or NPS scores)
  • Do employees report higher job satisfaction? (Mention turnover or engagement rates)
  • Is the firm gaining market share or entering new markets? (Provide figures if available)

Exam Tips

  • Define QC, QA and TQM clearly before analysing impacts.
  • Use real‑world examples (e.g., Toyota, Samsung, or a local SME) to illustrate each impact.
  • Link every benefit of TQM to at least one of the four business objectives.
  • When asked to evaluate, weigh advantages against challenges and consider short‑term vs long‑term effects.
  • Remember to mention benchmarking and the relationship between TQM and other operations concepts.

Create an account or Login to take a Quiz

27 views
0 improvement suggestions

Log in to suggest improvements to this note.